In the realm of child welfare, the role of government agencies and Child Welfare Agencies (CUAs) in Philadelphia has raised some pressing questions. How can the Philadelphia Department of Human Services (DHS) make final decisions regarding child placement, even against the determinations of CUAs, while claiming immunity from the consequences of those decisions? This issue raises concerns about the allocation of responsibility within the child welfare system.
It appears that CUAs were established as a mechanism for Philadelphia DHS to transfer the risks associated with child placement while retaining the authority to make the ultimate decisions regarding child safety. This has created an uneven distribution of responsibility and consequences within the system.
One key point of contention is the immunity that DHS enjoys compared to the CUAs. While DHS can make the final call on child placement and escape the legal ramifications of those decisions, CUAs are left exposed. This stark contrast in accountability begs the question: should DHS provide more support to CUAs, given their unique vulnerability? Alternatively, should DHS be allowed to override CUA decisions if their agency is open to risks that DHS is largely protected against?
The current system seems to prioritize the power and authority of DHS while potentially leaving CUAs in precarious situations. To ensure a fair and balanced approach to child welfare, it may be time to reevaluate the distribution of responsibility and immunity within the system. By addressing these concerns, we can work towards a child welfare system that places the best interests of children at its core while ensuring that accountability is equally shared among all stakeholders.
This brief article stems from a wider discussion that was recently carried by The NeoLiberal Round Podcast entitled: Case Management, CYS and Homelessness News Ft. David Fair of TP4C available on our YouTube channel and Spotify Podcast platform in video and on all major podcast platform such as Apple Podcast, Google Podcast, Amazon Music, the Audible, Radio Public etc. You can subscribe for free and find your podcast stream by visiting our main podcast platform: https://anchor.fm/theneoliberal. Donate to our podcast at https://anchor.fm/thneoliberal/support.
This article is submitted by Renaldo McKenzie, author of Neoliberalism, Globalization, Income Inequality, Poverty and Resistance and the upcoming Book, Neoliberal Globalization Reconsidered, Neo-Capitalism and the Death of Nations. Follow Renaldo on Twitter: https://twitter.com/renaldomckenzie.
Subscribe to The NeoLiberal Post and email us at [email protected].
Donate to The NeoLiberal Post
Make a one-time donation
Make a monthly donation
Make a yearly donation
Choose an amount
Or enter a custom amount
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
DonateDonate monthlyDonate yearlyVisit our bookshop and access our services and books:
The Neoliberal Book Store – The Neoliberal (renaldocmckenzie.com)
Subscribe to the podcast on any stream or our YouTube channel https://youtube.com/@renaldomckenzie. Find your podcast stream by going to https://anchor.fm/theneoliberal and donate to us at https://anchor.fm/theneoliberal/support.
The Neoliberal Post, The NeoLiberal Journal, The NeoLiberal blog and The NeoLiberal Round is a production of member of The NeoLiberal Corporation by Renaldo McKenzie, Serving the world the world today to solve tomorrow’s challenges by making popular what was the monopoly. Https://theneoliberal.com.
